Battlelines Home

About the Book Comments
& Press Release
About the Authors Photo
Slide Show
Music by
Marc
Chapter
Summaries
Order The Book

Comments about the book

MWSA Book Review

Battlelines

Authors:  LtCol David B. Brown, USMC (Ret)

              Tiffany Brown Holmes

Publisher:  iUniverse

Reviewer: Bill McDonald – President of the MWSA

Company F, 2nd Battalion, 5th Marines – Their History

Retired USMC Lt. Col. David Brown and his daughter, Tiffany Brown Holmes, team up to write the definitive history of one of the best fighting units in the Vietnam War. They finally share with the rest of the world, the real history and the stories of one of America’s finest fighting units from the Vietnam War – Company F, 2nd Battalion, 5th Marines. Their history is told with much pride in a book called “Battlelines.” The book gives us the unit’s history through personal accounts of those who served from 1966 through 1971. It is all about real heroes and brotherhood and team work; but it is also about death, wounds and PTSD. It is about shared experiences in hell and funny stories as well.

The authors did a great job of piecing this unit’s history together so that it flows as one story as you read the book. There are some memories that hurt and will bring tears and some that may bring a smile. This book is about real men facing life and death and taking care of each other in the process. This is what the Marines are all about and this unit is one of the finest examples of that spirit.

There were at least two men who were awarded the Medal of Honor and the unit had a host of other men receive various and numerous medals for heroic deeds. But this unit also got more than its share of Purple Hearts (for wounds received while in combat). “Fox Company” even got a Presidential Unit Citation for the battle for Hue. This was not some garrison troop that went out on an occasional patrol. This was a fighting force to be reckoned with as the NVA and VC forces found out.

If you were only going to read one book about the Marines in Vietnam then this would be that one book you should read. It honors not only this unit but all Marines. It is well written and well researched and was obviously a labor of love for the authors.

This book receives the MWSA’s HIGHEST BOOK RATING - FIVE STARS!

MWSA's 2006 Gold Medal Award for Memoirs

               

 

Received semi-finalist award for the 2006 Independent Publisher Book Awards-Historical/Military Fiction category

See the Marine Gazette Review

Oliver L. North, USMC (Ret.)

“In Battlelines, Lieutenant Colonel Dave Brown and his daughter, Tiffany, have captured the reality of war.  Their chronicle of comradeship forged in the crucible of combat is a must-read for anyone who cares about soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines who fight our country’s battles.”

Martin Brandtner, LtGen, USMC (Ret.)

“Battlelines…is a tribute to the brave Marines of Fox Company, 2/5, who fought in some of the sharpest battles of the war.  I fought alongside Dave Brown and his Marines, and can attest to the courage and tenacity displayed by the men of Fox Company.”

O.K. Steele, MGen, USMC (Ret.)

“Battlelines is a superb memoir on human behavior and the raw emotions felt by those who must constantly face the dangers of either closing or defending that last 600 meters against an aggressive, determined, and often-unseen enemy.  Implicit in the telling is a portrait of unsurpassed courage, steadfastness, and a sense of mutual affection for one another that can only be derived from men who find themselves together under fire.”


Lt Gerard Thomas, Jr., WWII (Okinawa Marine)

Dear Ms. Holmes--my son Patrick Thomas (Irving J. H.--Texas History) gave me a copy of the book you and your father put together about Fox Company 2/5/1.  It was well done and I enjoyed reading it although it stimulated thoughts and memories of unpleasant happenings--perhaps I should say many of such since it was not all unpleasant.  I was a company officer-platoon leader with K/2/8 2MarDiv from 6/44 to 12/45.  In fact 8RCT relieved the l  MarDiv when we moved on line at the southern end of Okinawa in July or August or thereabouts in l945.  The fact that a regiments could cover the area of responsibility for a division should give one a pretty good idea of what sort of shape lst Div. was in.  I never had the pleasure of running into your father while on duty but did meet some of the better known characters of  my era of service--Col. Edson and Maj Crow. Chamberline, etc. Thanks for he note you wrote on my book .  Thanks also to you and your father for a job well done.  Sincerely, Gerard T. Thomas, Jr. (Semper Fi)

 

Chris Brown, President F/2/5 Vietnam Association

I have just started reading Dave and Tiffany Brown's book "Battlelines". I

couldn't wait until I finished it to tell you how I feel reading it.

I am up through the Union II era and I must say that it is well written and

really captures the day to day feelings of the men who served with our

company. Having gone to the reunions and developing the strong friendships

with men like Sam Henderson, Sam Jones, George Burgett and so many more that

when reading about their exploits with Fox Company you feel like your with

them as they go through their day to day patrols, operations, etc. As most

of you know at the end of each reunion we say a prayer and read the names of

our KIA's. After reading this book, listening to those names being read will

have a whole new meaning for me. If you haven't purchased the book yet I

would strongly recommend it.

Semper Fi!

Chris

 

Bob Rinehart 11/10/05

Dave:

I just finished the book this afternoon. I found it bone honest and candid.....war as it really is from the ground pounder's perspective....not often very pleasant at all to envision.....conveying clearly that camaraderie very quickly becomes a central element during combat operations - and underscores why fellow combatants want and need to have reunions to revisit some of the most impactful experiences in their lives.  It was helpful/interesting also for someone like me who in peacetime commanded a rifle platoon and a weapons platoon that was fully staffed, to read frequently about a company in combat that at some points would be very undermanned, only have one or two officers and would have Sergeants and Corporals running a platoon. It brought forth that sense of pride to see how each marine stepped up and took charge as needed. You move forward with what you've got.

 
The book hangs together well even though you and Tiffany must have been piecing together anecdotes from a lot of people - good on both of you. I am sure all of the Marines from Fox are finding real value in what you have put together for them.  My hat is off to you for such a magnanimous and wonderful achievement. Proud to call you a friend.

 
All the best,

 
Bob

 

Marc Waszkiewicz 11/14/05

Dave and all my fellow Fox mud/blood brothers:

I just finished the book and cannot believe the profound impact it has made upon me.  While reading it, I was right back there with you guys... sweating and grumbling; joking and laughing; screaming and fighting; and, yes, crying too.  Riveting.  Brutal.  Clear.  Concise.  Honest.

I don't think some of you know, but I had served almost a year in-country at 11th Marines (artillery) Battalion HQ in the Fire Direction Center where one of my jobs was plotting the locations of "all friendlies" in the 5th Marines TAOR with little colored map pins on a wall sized map board.  Also, as watch sergeant, I monitored radio communications from all 5th Marines' units, as we tried to make sure you were not fired upon by friendly artillery while in the heat of contact.  During that time I observed that 2/5 was the "go to gang" when anyone needed help and that Fox Company was the company of choice when the chips were down.  For that reason, I extended my tour an extra six months (two times in a row) to serve with Fox Company as your artillery F.O. (forward observer.)  I have never regretted my decision despite numerous wounds received and the unpleasant aftermath of PTSD. 

Now that I have read the first hand accounts of what you all were experiencing while I was "watching from my underground bunker" coupled with the actual experiences of almost a year with Fox Company in the field, I have now been able to piece together many events that I had only listened to over the radio sets. 

This book has conveyed the history of a combat unit like no other oral history I have read.  I only have two regrets.  One, that I was unable to complete my second extension because of being seriously wounded and, two, that I cannot do it all over again!  However, this book has allowed me to do both, at least vicariously.

Semper Fi,

Marc (Cpl. Ski/ Sgt. Ski) Waszkiewicz

Viet Nam 1967-68-69

 

Rich Carter 11/24/05

I wish to extend my thanks and appreciation to you and Tiffany for all your time and efforts in exploring the trials and tribulations of Fox Company during its deployment to Vietnam.  The book gave me the opportunity to view the war from the perspective of  Marines and Corpsmen in all the phases of the Vietnam War.  You both did a great service to the Corps and anyone in general in re-creating day-to-day experiences and feelings generated by "those who actually fought the war." 

Being diagnosed and treated for severe PTSD since 1994, I found it difficult at times to read some of the graphic details and suffering which was part of our existence in the field.  However, in actuality, it helped me and my condition; obliging me to confront so many unresolved issues.  In the process of reading, I suffered severe vivid nightmares of incidents that never affected me during the entire time of my over 12 month tour in Nam.  I suppose it has been the same for most of us who witnessed first hand the horror and destruction of the human body; especially those with whom our lives became so interwoven with.   What I believe got us through was our determination to live up to the high standards of the Corps, and also because we relied so much on each other.   

I did have some good dreams while reading your book.  Those dreams gave me another opportunity to interact with my fellow Marines and Corpsmen and to do something I never had the opportunity to do in Nam until now....to say "goodbye" to them and be another step closer to closure which I realize may never happen.

Respectfully, 

Rich Carter

 

 

 

 

Contact LtCol David B. Brown, USMC (Ret.) Contact Tiffany Brown Holmes

Hit Counter